FREE CONSULTATION | CALL 24/7

No Fee Unless You Win

FREE CONSULTATION | CALL 24/7

No Fee Unless You Win

FREE CONSULTATION | CALL 24/7

No Fee Unless You Win

FREE CONSULTATION | CALL 24/7

No Fee Unless You Win

Can a Health Insurer Take Money From Your NYC Injury Settlement?

Can a Health Insurer Take Money From Your NYC Injury Settlement?

On This Page

How New York Law Protects Your Injury Settlement From Health Insurers

Key Takeaways: In most cases, a private health insurer cannot take money from your NYC personal injury settlement, because New York’s anti-subrogation law, GOL § 5-335, presumes that settlements do not include medical costs that insurance already paid. This protection generally covers personal injury, medical malpractice, and wrongful death settlements, whether reached in litigation or before a lawsuit is filed. Self-funded ERISA employer plans are generally not bound by state anti-subrogation laws. The law does not stop Medicare, Medicaid, or workers’ compensation carriers from seeking reimbursement under their own statutory rights, and it does not apply to No-Fault benefits. Charitable, municipal, and SUNY hospitals may also hold liens under Lien Law § 189 if they send proper written notice before settlement money is paid. Save your medical records and bills, ask any payer for the legal basis of its claim, and have every lien reviewed before you sign a release.

In most cases, a private health insurer cannot take money from your NYC personal injury settlement to pay itself back for medical bills it covered. New York’s anti-subrogation law, General Obligations Law § 5-335, generally blocks health insurers from claiming reimbursement once you settle a personal injury, medical malpractice, or wrongful death claim. There are important exceptions. Medicare, Medicaid, workers’ compensation carriers, self-funded ERISA plans, and certain hospitals may still have rights against your recovery.

If a health plan or hospital has sent you a lien notice, get help before you sign any settlement papers. The Newman Firm helps injured New Yorkers deal with insurance companies and challenge improper lien claims. Call 718-896-2700 or contact us now to talk about your case.

Man in jacket and jeans reading letter while seated on brownstone steps beside wrought iron railing and envelopes

Understanding the Anti-Subrogation Law in New York

New York’s legislature passed GOL 5-335 in 2009 to limit health insurers’ reimbursement and subrogation claims against injury settlements. Before then, many injured people saw a large share of their settlement go back to their health insurer. Under the law, settling a claim generally ended the insurer’s right to subrogation, reimbursement, or a lien against the settlement. A 2013 amendment clarified that insurers have no such rights against a settling plaintiff or defendant, except where a statutory right of reimbursement exists.

The Conclusive Presumption That Protects Your Money

The statute works through a legal presumption. Under New York General Obligations Law § 5-335(a), when a person settles a claim for personal injuries, medical, dental, or podiatric malpractice, or wrongful death, the law conclusively presumes that the settlement does not include compensation for health care costs, lost earnings, or other economic loss that has been or will be paid by a benefit provider. The protection applies whether you settle during a lawsuit or before one is filed. Because the settlement is treated as not covering those costs, the insurer generally has no basis to claim part of it unless a statutory right of reimbursement or federal preemption applies. The presumption applies to settlements, not to jury verdicts or judgments after trial.

What This Means for Health Insurer Reimbursement in NY

Since the settlement is presumed not to cover paid medical expenses, covered insurers generally lose any lien, subrogation, or reimbursement right for expenses they paid or are obligated to pay. Under GOL § 5-335(a), a person who settles a claim generally cannot be subject to a subrogation or reimbursement claim by an insurer, and the insurer has no lien or right of subrogation or reimbursement against the settling person or any other party to the settlement for those amounts. Subdivision (b) excludes Article 51 (No-Fault) additional first-party benefit subrogation claims, and the statute’s other carve-outs, including Medicare, Medicaid, and workers’ compensation, are also outside its protection. A letter from your health plan demanding repayment may not be enforceable after you settle.

Fully insured plans, including many employer plans governed by ERISA, are generally subject to GOL 5-335 because ERISA’s "savings clause" preserves state insurance laws. Self-funded ERISA plans are different. Courts have generally held that ERISA preempts state anti-subrogation laws for self-funded plans, so those plans may be able to enforce reimbursement clauses in their plan documents. Federal employee plans under FEHBA may also claim preemption. That is why reviewing the actual plan documents matters.

💡 Pro Tip: If your health plan sends a reimbursement demand, ask in writing for the full plan document and the specific legal basis for the claim. Do not assume the demand is valid.

When a Personal Injury Settlement Lien in New York Can Still Apply

The anti-subrogation law has limits. GOL § 5-335(c) states that it does not apply to Medicare or Medicaid, to benefits under Article 51 of the Insurance Law (No-Fault), or to workers’ compensation benefits. Medicare, Medicaid, and workers’ compensation each have their own statutory reimbursement rights and may recover from a settlement in the right circumstances. No-Fault works differently. A No-Fault insurer generally does not hold a lien on your settlement, but No-Fault benefits it paid (basic economic loss) cannot be recovered again from the at-fault driver. In some cases, the No-Fault carrier may seek recovery from another insurer through loss transfer or arbitration.

Payer Type Can It Generally Recover From Your Settlement? Key Authority
Private health insurer (fully insured) Generally no GOL § 5-335
Medicare Yes, subject to federal rules Statutory carve-out in GOL § 5-335
Medicaid Yes, subject to limits Statutory carve-out in GOL § 5-335
No-Fault (Article 51) Under certain circumstances Insurance Law Article 51
Workers’ compensation carrier Yes, in many cases Workers’ compensation law
Qualifying hospitals Potentially, if proper notice was given Lien Law § 189

No-Fault Benefits and Health Insurers

If you were hurt in a car crash, the interaction between No-Fault and health insurance can affect who pays what. No-Fault is generally the primary payer for the first $50,000 in basic economic loss, and health insurance usually covers expenses beyond that. Health insurers seeking reimbursement from auto accident recoveries have faced legal obstacles in New York, but the outcome depends on the facts and coverage type.

Hospital Liens: A Separate Settlement Lien NYC Victims Should Know

Some New York hospitals may have a separate legal right to be paid from your recovery. Under New York Lien Law § 189(1), charitable, municipal, and SUNY hospitals may hold a lien on a patient’s personal injury claim, lawsuit, or settlement for reasonable charges. The lien covers emergency and follow-up treatment for injuries, as long as the patient was admitted or given emergency treatment within one week after the injury. It is not a health insurer claim, and GOL § 5-335 generally does not eliminate it. The lien cannot exceed the amount of the recovery, and it does not apply to workers’ compensation recoveries.

The Notice Requirement Matters

A hospital lien is generally ineffective unless the hospital mails proper written notice, by registered or certified mail with postage prepaid, to the party alleged to be liable before any compensation is paid to the injured person, their attorney, or their legal representative. Lien Law § 189(1) also requires the hospital to mail a copy of the notice to the liability insurer. It separately requires filing and mailing an additional verified notice after discharge. If the hospital skips these steps or sends notice too late, the lien may not be enforceable.

Under Lien Law § 189(2), the hospital lien does not depend on a trial verdict. It can attach to judgments, to settlements of judgments, and to compromises reached before a lawsuit is filed. For more background, read our guide on medical liens on injury settlements.

NYSHIP Members Face Their Own Considerations

If you are a New York State employee, retiree, or dependent covered by NYSHIP, your plan may have its own subrogation process. Whether those rights can be enforced against a settlement may depend on GOL § 5-335 and the plan’s structure. Private insurance, self-funded ERISA plans, Medicare, and Medicaid may each follow different rules.

NYSHIP’s materials also describe record requests, which let members or their attorneys get claim payment information. In a settlement, those records show what the plan says it paid and what it may try to claim. Confirm the current procedure directly with NYSHIP before you submit a request.

Practical Steps for Injury Settlement Protection

Protecting your settlement starts long before you sign a release. These steps may help:

  • Keep every medical bill, Explanation of Benefits statement, and lien letter you receive.
  • Find out whether your health plan is fully insured, self-funded, or government-sponsored.
  • Ask any payer claiming a lien to state the statute or plan language it relies on.
  • Check whether hospital lien notices were sent properly and on time.
  • Keep evidence of the accident and your injuries, since it may support your negligence claim.

Keep your filing deadline in mind while lien questions are being sorted out. In New York, many personal injury claims must be filed within three years under CPLR § 214. Medical malpractice claims generally have a 2.5-year deadline under CPLR § 214-a, and wrongful death claims generally must be filed within two years under EPTL § 5-4.1. Claims against municipalities often require a Notice of Claim within 90 days under General Municipal Law § 50-e. Under CPLR § 1411, your recovery is reduced by your share of fault. New York’s pure comparative negligence rule (CPLR § 1411(a)) still applies to most injury claims, such as premises liability and wrongful death. For motor vehicle personal injury actions subject to Insurance Law Article 51 and commenced on or after May 26, 2026, CPLR § 1411(b) bars recovery if your fault is greater than the defendant’s fault or the combined fault of all defendants. If your fault is not greater, your damages are reduced by your share. Speaking with a personal injury lien lawyer early can help you protect both your claim and your settlement.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can my private health insurer take part of my New York settlement?

In most cases, no. GOL § 5-335 generally ends a fully insured private plan’s lien and reimbursement rights once you settle. Self-funded ERISA plans and federal employee plans may be able to enforce reimbursement under federal law.

2. Does Medicare or Medicaid have to be repaid?

In many cases, yes. GOL § 5-335 expressly excludes Medicare and Medicaid, so both may seek reimbursement under their own statutory rules.

3. Can a hospital put a lien on my settlement?

Under certain circumstances, yes. Lien Law § 189 lets qualifying hospitals claim a lien if they send proper written notice before settlement money is paid.

4. Does the anti-subrogation law apply if I settle before filing suit?

Generally, yes. GOL § 5-335 applies to settlements "whether in litigation or otherwise," so pre-suit settlements are generally covered.

5. What if I have NYSHIP coverage?

NYSHIP runs its own subrogation and record request process. Review your plan’s rules and ask for payment records before you finalize any settlement.

Keeping More of What You Recover

New York law gives injured people strong protection against health insurer reimbursement claims, but that protection has limits. GOL § 5-335 generally shields your NYC personal injury settlement from fully insured private health plans. Medicare, Medicaid, workers’ compensation, self-funded ERISA plans, and properly noticed hospital liens may still apply. The outcome depends on your plan type, your recovery source, and the specific facts of your case.

Before you accept a settlement, make sure every lien claim has been reviewed carefully. The Newman Firm is available to answer your questions. Call 718-896-2700 or schedule your consultation today.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and results may vary. Consult an attorney about your specific circumstances.

Gregory S. Newman

He admitted to the New York Bar in 2007, with a J.D. from Touro College Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center and a B.A. from the University of Michigan. Recognized as a New York Metro Rising Star in 2016 and 2017 and a member of multiple bar associations.

Meet Our Attorneys
Contact Us
Get a Free Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

- As Seen On -
150+
FIVE-STAR REVIEWS
$ Millions
RECOVERED FOR OUR CLIENTS
40+
YEARS IN BUSINESS